Back to Case Studies
Heavy-Procedure IndustriesCommercial Bank

How to Run a Multi-Stage Loan Approval Workflow That Closes Fraud Gaps and Satisfies CBK

Who This Is For

You manage credit operations at a commercial bank or MFI. Loan approvals move through Credit, Legal, Risk, and Operations — multiple people, multiple sign-offs, physical files that get routed between desks. A fraud investigation happened, or you're worried one could. CBK examiners have reviewed the loan approval process before and found the documentation inconsistent. You need a structured workflow that actually enforces the process rather than assuming it's being followed.

The Problem

A nine-stage loan approval process managed through email threads, printed files, and shared drives isn't an enforced process — it's a series of good intentions with no structural guarantee. Nothing prevents stage 7 from being signed off before stage 4 is complete. Nothing stops a forged document from passing through the chain if the person reviewing it is busy or pressured. And when the investigation into a fraudulent disbursement starts, the audit trail is a collection of emails — some of which are missing, some forwarded out of sequence, some deleted. CBK examiners don't accept "the process exists" as evidence it was followed. They want to see documentation showing each approval stage was completed by the right role, in the right sequence, with the required supporting documents — for the specific file they're reviewing. When that documentation is fragmented across individual inboxes and physical files, the finding is functionally the same as if the process was never run at all.

What You Can Achieve

  • Every loan moves through every required approval stage in sequence — no stage can be skipped, no stage can be marked complete before the preceding one is done
  • Each approval is attributed to the individual who granted it, with their specific role, timestamp, and document trail — "who approved this?" has an unambiguous answer
  • CBK examiners reviewing loan files see complete, structured documentation for every disbursement — organized by stage, role, and the supporting documents submitted
  • Fraud attempts that rely on bypassing approval stages are blocked structurally — the workflow physically can't progress without the mandatory steps
  • When fraud does occur, the audit trail shows exactly where the process was bypassed and which specific individual made the decision — making internal accountability and external reporting far cleaner
  • Disbursement cycle time drops when approvals happen in a structured workflow rather than waiting for a physical file to reach the right desk

The Hakiki Workflow

  1. 1
    Loan Application ID & Amount Text

    Enter application reference number and loan amount (KES) — creates the case record

  2. 2
    Branch Selection Single Select

    Select originating branch — enables branch-level portfolio reporting and fraud pattern analysis

  3. 3
    Credit Score Verified Boolean

    Credit analyst confirms credit score has been obtained and meets minimum threshold — CRB check attached

  4. 4
    Income Verification Boolean

    Confirm income has been verified against payslips, bank statements, or business financials

  5. 5
    CRB Report Upload File Upload

    Upload CRB report — mandatory upload before Credit sign-off can proceed

  6. 6
    Security/Collateral Verified Boolean

    Confirm collateral has been physically inspected and title deed has been verified with lands registry

  7. 7
    Security Documents Upload File Upload

    Upload title deed, valuation report, and security agreement — all required before Legal sign-off

  8. 8
    Risk Appetite Approved Boolean

    Risk Officer confirms loan falls within credit policy risk parameters — with Risk Officer ID

  9. 9
    Credit Director Sign-Off Boolean

    Credit Director approves the credit decision — mandatory above defined threshold amounts

  10. 10
    Disbursement Account Confirmed Boolean

    Operations confirms disbursement account details match the application and KYC records

  11. 11
    Amount & Schedule Confirmed Boolean

    Confirm disbursement amount, schedule, and interest rate match the approved term sheet

  12. 12
    Disbursement Authorized Boolean

    Operations Manager authorizes disbursement — final gate before funds are released — with timestamp

HAKIKI Features Used

Multi-department sequential approval workflowMandatory file uploadsBoolean sign-off with role attributionStrict ordering (no skipping)Full audit trailPDF export for CBK review

See Hakiki in action

Build your first auditable workflow in minutes — no credit card required.

Get Started Free